The Best Coffee Syrup: Top 11 Reviewed

someone pouring coffee syrup into an iced coffee

In a rush? Our top choice for the best coffee syrup is DaVinci Gourmet Classic Coffee Syrup.

You don’t need to be a barista to enjoy your favorite coffee drinks.

Sometimes, all you need is a good syrup to step up your coffee-making game.

But there’s much more to buying one than just choosing a flavor. 

In this article, I’ll show you what the best coffee syrup options on the market are, and what to look for on the ingredient list.

Let’s pick your poison!

The Best Coffee Syrups – Our Top 11 Picks

DaVinci Gourmet Classic Coffee Syrup

DaVinci has been making coffee syrups for over 30 years now. And over time, they’ve really broadened their taste range. 

Aside from classic choices, such as caramel, chocolate and Irish cream, there are some pretty unusual ones too. The list is long, but habanero and peach chipotle definitely stood out the most to me. Spicy coffee is not for everyone, but those that like it will surely enjoy these syrups. 

Cane sugar is the sweetener of choice for this classic syrup line. But DaVinci does use other sweeteners in different lines, including sugar-free syrups. 

The brand prides itself in using only natural ingredients in all of its products. 

And the DaVinci syrup line is kosher certified, too. This means it’s in compliance with the strict policy of kosher food laws, including cleanliness, purity and quality. There are no shady ingredients!

  • Sweetener: Cane sugar
  • Sugar-free options: Yes
  • Flavor range: Huge
  • Standard packaging size: 25.4 fluid ounces
Check Current Price

Jordan’s Skinny Syrups 

This is a well known brand in the world of syrups. It started out making cocktails, but over the course of 12 years, it developed different syrup lines, including coffee syrups. 

Jordan’s Skinny Syrups are marketed as guilt-free because they have zero sugar, calories and carbs. You can be on pretty much any kind of diet, including keto and gluten-free, and enjoy your coffee spiced up with one of these syrups.

This little set contains all the classic coffee flavors, like hazelnut, mocha and caramel syrup. But if you’re looking for something more unique, Jordan’s Skinny Syrups can do that, too. 

Glazed donut and toasted marshmallow are my personal favorites.

  • Sweetener: Sucralose
  • Sugar-free options: Yes
  • Flavor range: Huge
  • Standard packaging size: 25.4 fluid ounces
Check Current Price

Torani Fall Winter Syrup 4 Pack

There are some pretty big names in the world of syrup on this list, and Torani is definitely one of them. That comes as no surprise given the fact that they’ve been doing this for almost a hundred years.

They have over 150 different flavors from nutty to fruity, which is pretty impressive. To be honest, I probably couldn’t think of more than 20. 

In terms of ingredients, Torani syrup sticks to the natural ones, all the while avoiding common allergens such as peanuts, tree nuts, dairy, soy and eggs. 

As for the sweetener, cane sugar is used in this line. There’s also a sugar-free line, which uses sucralose and ace-K.

The Fall Winter syrup pack comes with all the classic cold weather flavors. You’ve got pumpkin pie, peppermint, salted caramel and brown sugar cinnamon. 

But if you’re feeling a bit more adventurous, you should definitely try butterscotch or Italian eggnog.

  • Sweetener: Cane sugar
  • Sugar-free options: Yes
  • Flavor range: Huge
  • Standard packaging size: 25.4 fluid ounces
Check Current Price

Upouria Coffee Syrup Variety Pack

Upouria coffee syrups might not come in 50 different flavors, but the brand sure does cover all the most iconic coffee flavors out there. 

This variety pack comes with all-time favorites like mocha, French vanilla and caramel flavor.

I love that you also get three pumps included in the purchase. Sure, you could find them in pretty much any store. But it’s nice not to have to go to the trouble of buying them yourself.

One note to those that are watching what they eat – these syrups have approximately 90 calories per serving.

The sugar-free line is limited, but it’s there. You get to choose between the two, probably most popular flavors: French vanilla and caramel. For these two syrups, sucralose is used.

  • Sweetener: Sugar
  • Sugar-free options: Yes
  • Flavor range: Limited
  • Standard packaging size: 25.4 fluid ounces
Check Current Price

Holy Kakow Cafe Organic 

This brand of organic coffee syrup uses only responsibly-sourced ingredients, which is always a plus. These syrups are handcrafted and packed in beautiful glass bottles. 

I’m a sucker for good packaging, and this is definitely it.

One thing to note – if you notice liquid separation in your bottle, don’t throw it away. It didn’t go bad. This normally happens with all-natural organic crafted syrups. You just need to shake it well before use.

Holy Kakow has a decent range of flavors. There are classic options like vanilla and hazelnut, as well as more interesting tastes, such as lavender and rose. 

All syrups contain organic evaporated cane juice as a sweetener. It’s made of sugar cane, but goes through less processing than table sugar, so it keeps all the good nutrients. 

  • Sweetener: Organic evaporated cane juice
  • Sugar-free options: No
  • Flavor range: Decent
  • Standard packaging size: 25.4 fluid ounces
Check Current Price

Ghirardelli Coffee Sauce

I don’t usually like plastic packaging, but I’ve got to admit – this is as premium as plastic can get. 

The gold-toned squeeze bottle really looks and feels like a high-end product, and so does the content inside. 

This 5-bottle set is specially designed for spicing up espresso-based drinks. And to enhance the flavor of rich-bodied coffee, you need a rich syrup. 

Well, that’s exactly what Ghirardelli is. In fact, it’s called a sauce because of its thicker consistency.

Unfortunately, there are no sugar-free options. What’s more, the syrup is manufactured in a facility that makes tree nuts, eggs and milk. This means it can contain any of these ingredients in traces. So if you have allergies, this might not be the best syrup for you.

  • Sweetener: Fructose
  • Sugar-free options: No
  • Flavor range: Very limited
  • Standard packaging size: 16 fluid ounces
Check Current Price

Starbucks Naturally Flavored Coffee Syrup

Given the brand’s popularity, it was about time Starbucks made their syrups available to all of us. 

In this Starbucks syrup variety pack, they gave us the most popular flavors: vanilla, hazelnut and caramel. 

With just these three options, you can make tons of the most popular Starbucks drinks at home.

And Starbucks really nailed these flavors, let me tell you. The vanilla is sweet and rich, the caramel syrup is smooth and buttery, while the hazelnut is strong and nutty. 

As for the sweetener, the label just states “sugar.” Unfortunately, there’s no sugar-free version. 

In case you’re wondering, each serving adds around 90 calories to your drink.

  • Sweetener: Sugar
  • Sugar-free options: No
  • Flavor range: Very limited
  • Standard packaging size: 12.17 fluid ounces
Check Current Price

Monin Gourmet Flavorings Premium Coffee Collection

Monin is a name you’ve probably heard of, since you can see the bottles displayed everywhere, from shop racks to bars and cafes. 

This is a brand well known for making high-quality syrups.

The flavor range is practically endless. Hickory smoke and golden turmeric might be the oddest options I’ve seen. But after reading each label, I would definitely try them out.

The Monin syrup line is made with pure cane sugar and contains only natural flavors. They’re GMO, dairy and gluten-free, as well as kosher certified. So you can rest assured they’re made in compliance with strict food law policy.

I was pleasantly surprised to find out that there are 15 different sugar-free flavors. Aside from classic options like hazelnut and vanilla, there are tons of other nutty and fruity flavors you can drink guilt-free.

  • Sweetener: Cane sugar
  • Sugar-free options: Yes
  • Flavor range: Huge
  • Standard packaging size: 25.4 fluid ounces
Check Current Price

Wholesome Yum Keto Coffee Syrup 

Compared to the rest of the syrups I reviewed, this brand has rather limited flavor options. 

Well, two to be exact: vanilla and hazelnut. 

But if quality wins over quantity, then Wholesome Yum syrups definitely deserve a spot on this list.

These syrups are naturally sweetened with a blend of monk fruit extract and allulose. They are both safe for diabetics, as well as children and even pets! Not that you should feed your furry friends syrup, but it’s good to know it can’t hurt them.

No calories, no carbs and definitely no artificial ingredients. You can be on the most rigorous diet out there, and you can still enjoy your coffee with these syrups.

The packaging is cute, but I’m not a fan of the tiny size. There are around 12 servings per bottle, so you can down it in a matter of days. Unless you buy it in batches, you’ll be spending way too much time shopping online.

  • Sweetener: Monk fruit extract and allulose
  • Sugar-free options: Yes
  • Flavor range: Very limited
  • Standard packaging size: 12 fluid ounces
Check Current Price

Liquid Planet Organic Coconut Coffee Syrup

These syrups have a thick consistency that makes them great for coffee, but ice cream and pastries as well.

There are seven flavors available: almond, caramel, coconut, hazelnut, Irish creme, raspberry and vanilla syrup. Not the most exciting options, but they’re all exceptionally tasty. 

There are no artificial flavors – they’re all extracted from plants.

And since they’re made with natural ingredients only, you can expect some settling to occur. When that happens, just shake the bottle and you’ll get a uniform mixture again. 

They don’t contain any preservatives, but due to the organic cane sugar, their shelf life is over a year.

In my opinion, the only real downside is that there’s no sugar-free option. So if you’re on a diet, you might want to stay away from this syrup.

  • Sweetener: Organic cane sugar
  • Sugar-free options: No
  • Flavor range: Decent
  • Standard packaging size: 25.4 fluid ounces
Check Current Price

Amoretti Premium Classic Syrups 

Here’s a nice gift idea for a fellow coffee addict. 

This cute little set contains the three most popular flavors: hazelnut, caramel, and vanilla syrup. 

But there are tons of other flavors available, from tres leches and rocky road to jasmine and anise. 

But my personal favorite? Birthday cake. That way for the 364 days of the year when I’m not blowing candles, I can at least pretend it’s my special day by adding this to my coffee.

These syrups are naturally flavored and without artificial preservatives. They contain cane sugar, except for the sugar-free options, of course. These use sucralose instead. 

  • Sweetener: Cane sugar
  • Sugar-free options: Yes
  • Flavor range: Huge
  • Standard packaging size: 25.4 fluid ounces
Check Current Price

Things To Consider When Buying Coffee Syrup

lots of bottles of coffee syrup

Buying coffee syrup doesn’t just revolve around picking the perfect flavor. 

In fact, that’s the easiest part.

Just look at the labels on syrups from different brands. Their ingredients and nutritional values can differ quite a bit. 

To pick the best one, here are some things to keep in mind.

Which Sweetener Is It Made Of?

Coffee syrups are supposed to be sweet – but that doesn’t mean they have to contain sugar. 

There are tons of different ingredients that are commonly used as sweeteners. 

These include corn syrup, fructose, dextrose and cane sugar. 

All of these are derived from natural sources. But that doesn’t mean they all have the same effect on our bodies

Cane sugar is among the healthier options, especially when unrefined. It’s low in calories, but contains amino acids, minerals and antioxidants. 

Sugar we know as table sugar is derived from sugar beets. It goes through extensive processing, which uses bone char. So not only does it lack nutrients, but it’s also not vegan or vegetarian friendly.

Then, there are artificial sweeteners. They’re several thousand times sweeter than sugar, but have zero calories.

How’s that possible, you might wonder?

As you probably know, our tongues are covered with receptors that send signals to our brains to identify a taste.

Artificial sweeteners have a similar chemical structure to sugar, so they activate our sweet receptors. But since our bodies can’t break them down, they have zero calories.

Generally, artificial sweeteners have a bad reputation, but they’re not all the same. The most common artificial sweeteners used are sucralose and aspartame. 

Sucralose has no known negative effect on our bodies. In fact, it’s believed to improve digestion and immune function, although further studies are yet to prove this.

Aspartame, on the other hand, has been linked with serious health issues. These include cancer and cardiovascular diseases. Again, this is yet to be scientifically proven. But until it is, this isn’t the best choice of sweetener.

Coffee Syrups VS Other Types Of Flavored Syrups

someone pouring coffee syrup into an iced coffee

A coffee syrup is, indeed, formulated with coffee drinks in mind. 

What makes it different from other kinds of flavored syrup out there is that it dissolves well in both hot and cold drinks. 

Here are what those other types of syrups are:

Cocktail Syrup

These are made to be used for mixed drinks, both alcoholic and virgin. 

Cocktail syrups are easily dissolved in cold drinks, but they might not perform as well mixed in hot beverages. 

That means you can get away with using them to make iced coffee, but it’s probably not the best idea to use them in your hot coffee drinks.

Cooking Syrup

This type of flavored syrup is intended to be used with different textures, including liquids. 

For that reason, they can work with coffee too. 

But keep in mind that they might be higher in calories than coffee syrups.

Agave Nectar

This syrup tastes like molasses with a slight caramel tinge. 

The darker the syrup, the sweeter the taste. 

It’s high in fructose but low GI and light in flavor. For that reason, it’s used more as an alternative natural sweetener than a flavored syrup.

3 Delicious Coffee Syrup Drink Ideas

peppermint mocha in a mug

Okay, so you’ve found the perfect syrup. 

Now what?

To get you started, here are a few classic coffee drink ideas you can try at home.

Hot Peppermint Mocha

This drink reminds me of Christmas. 

But nothing’s stopping you from drinking it every day of the year.

Here’s what you’ll need to make this beverage:

  • 2 tablespoons cocoa powder
  • 2 shots espresso
  • 1 cup steamed milk
  • 2 tablespoons peppermint syrup
  • Whipped cream 
  • Chocolate sauce
  • Mini chocolate chips for decoration (optional)

And here’s how to make it, step by step:

  1. Put two tablespoons of cocoa powder in the bottom of your cup. 
  2. Pour in two shots of espresso and stir until you get a uniform mixture.
  3. Add the peppermint syrup and steamed milk. Stir until all the ingredients are nicely combined. 
  4. Top it with whipped cream and a drizzle of chocolate sauce. Sprinkle on some mini chocolate chips for decoration, if desired.

On hot days, substitute steamed with cold milk and add some ice cubes. 

Voila, you’ve got yourself an iced peppermint mocha!

(I wasn’t kidding about drinking these all year round.)

Pumpkin Spice Latte

There’s nothing better than a hot pumpkin spice latte to make a cold winter day a little warmer. 

This is one of my favorite coffee drinks to make at home.

Here’s the list of ingredients:

  • 2 tablespoons pumpkin spice syrup
  • ¾ cup steamed milk
  • 1 shot espresso
  • Cinnamon sticks
  • Whipped cream
  • Ground cinnamon

Once you’ve got everything you need, here’s what you need to do:

  1. Add 2 tablespoons of pumpkin spice syrup to a cup.
  2. Make a single shot of espresso and pour it into the same cup. Stir well.
  3. Add the steamed milk. 
  4. Top with whipped cream and cinnamon. Add a cinnamon stick for extra decoration.

And that’s pretty much it! 

Caffe Mocha

The most popular coffee drinks are often the simplest in terms of ingredients. 

The caffe Mocha is a good example.  

You only need a couple of things:

  • 2 tablespoons chocolate syrup
  • 2 shots espresso 
  • 1 cup steamed milk
  • 1 cup heavy whipping cream
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract

And here’s how to make it:

  1. Add 2 tablespoons of chocolate syrup to a cup.
  2. Make a double shot of espresso, then pour it over the syrup.
  3. Gently pour the steamed milk in until the cup is almost full.
  4. Grab a bowl and mix the whipping cream with vanilla extract. Beat it until soft peaks start to form. This shouldn’t take more than 5 minutes.
  5. Top the drink with the whipped cream mixture.

This recipe is pretty straightforward, so you won’t have any trouble nailing it in a single shot.

The Final Verdict

Enjoying your favorite coffee drink without having to leave the house is pretty convenient. 

It’s also pretty simple, if you have a good coffee syrup at your disposal.

You can’t go wrong by choosing DaVinci Gourmet Classic Coffee Syrup. The flavor range is endless, and the ingredients are of natural origin and high quality. 

And speaking of flavors – don’t be afraid of stepping out of your comfort zone. There are some really unique and yummy options out there. So have fun experimenting!